Friday 22 January 2021

Comparing Building Regulations for Energy - Scotland and England

 

Development of new homes in Glasgow by CCG Homes, Installation by Arc-Tech

New regulations have been published for Part L building regulations in England.

Let's take a quick look at how they compare to Scotland, where almost all new homes now come with solar panels.

The building regulations work by defining a specification for a 'Notional Dwelling' - read this article for more detail of how it works

In the table below I have shown a selection of the more significant requirements for each.  It is evident that not only do both Notional Houses include solar PV, but that the England requirement is much higher.

Housebuilders do not have to build the Notional House specification, but they must equal or exceed its performance.  The scope for reducing the solar provision by increasing the insulation performance of building elements such as walls, roofs and windows (collectively often referred to as fabric measures)  is limited in the new English regulations, which equal or exceed the fabric requirements in Scotland.


‘Notional Dwelling’ Summary Specification

Selected Requirements

 

Scotland 2015 (Gas Package)

England 2021

U Values in W/m2K

 

 

External Walls

0.17

0.18

Floors

0.15

0.13

Roofs

0.11

0.11

Doors

1.40

1.00

Windows

1.40

1.20

Air Permeability

7 m3/h.m2 at 50Pa

5 m3/h.m2 at 50Pa

Heating

Gas boiler 89% efficiency

Gas boiler 89.5% efficiency

Heat Emitter Type

Regular radiators

Low temperature heating 55°C flow

Heat Recovery

Instantaneous Waste Water 45% efficient

Instantaneous Waste Water 36% efficient

Solar PV in kWp

Smaller of

(a) Total floor area (m2) x 0.01

 

(b) 0.3 x roof area based on 30 degree roof pitch x 0.12

 

 

40% of dwelling floor area/6.5

Example solar PV for 85m2 house with two floors

 

0.85kWp

 

 

2.6kWp