Tuesday, 4 October 2016

Thin Film Solar PV vs Silicon Wafer - Which is Better?

A guest article by Dr KT Tan cuts through the marketing to find out

Figure 1 (Source: Jethro Betcke, Oldenburg University, Germany)

Thin film solar PV was hailed as the next big thing in solar nearly a decade ago. Then, crystalline silicon wafer (c-Si) cells occupied more than 80% of the market share compared to thin film PV (1). There was a high anticipation in the industry for thin film PV to position itself for a run at c-Si and dominate the market for the near future. However, 10 years on, history shows that not only did thin film fail to conquer the market, but its market share has subsequently declined to only 7% (2).

Obviously, one major factor was due to the collapse of the price for c-Si cells, which quickly wiped off the cost advantages of thin film technologies. This blog is not going to discuss the reasons for this distorted market competition, caused mainly by the exponential expansion of production in c-Si cells, but to question and compare the technical merits of thin film PV versus c-Si.

Do thin film PV technologies have an arsenal of special features to outperform c-Si cells? 

Low Light Performance

The first common belief is that thin film solar PV performs better in low light conditions or diffuse sunlight (for example on a cloudy day). But is this true? The fact that this has been heavily promoted by the marketing guys is because these two technologies do have different spectrum responses to solar light. In other words, their ability to convert solar energy to electricity varies at different wavelengths. In general, the average wavelength in diffuse sunlight is shorter (i.e. more blue) that of direct sunlight – so if you have a spectral response peaking at short wavelengths, e.g. thin film amorphous silicon (a-Si), then you would perform better under diffuse conditions than clear sky conditions.

Figure 1 for shows the different spectrum responses of different solar technologies against the power of sunlight of different wavelengths at sea level at mid-lattitudes of Earth (called AM1.5).  Crystalline monocrystalline silicon (labelled m-Si) is compared against different thin film solar technologies based on amorphous silicon (a-Si), Copper Indium Gallium Selenide (CIGS) and Cadmium Telluride (CdTe).

If you look at Figure 1, you probably would have noticed that not all thin film technologies have the same performance response to differing light wavelengths. Thin film CIGS solar panels, for example, have a broad spectrum response akin to mono-crystalline wafer cells (m-Si), so based on this their performance in diffuse lighting conditions would be little different to m-Si.

Amorphous Silicon has a quite significantly different spectral response to crystalline silicon, with a greater response to low wavelength light.  So how do they compare in field trials? Figure 2 illustrates the results of a comparative study between a-Si and c-Si on a cloudy day. On average, the tests show an increase in energy generated of 15% for a-Si at low irradiance levels below 260 W/m2.  (Note: the tests were published by NexPower, a manufacturer of amorphous Silicon panels)
Figure 2 (Source: NexPower In-house test report)

However, performing better on cloudy days is of little benefit if it is combined with performing less well on sunny days (when more energy can be collected). If this were the case then the advantage of thin film PV under diffuse conditions might be a complete red-herring created by the marketing gurus.

A recent research project (3) supported by the Deutsche Bunderstiftung Umwelt (German Federal Foundation for the Environment) compared several solar module types (including thin film and c-Si) under North German Climatological conditions in a side by side trial for a year, and it turned out that no significant difference between the performances of the different type of modules could be found .


Let’s move on to the second common claim, that thin film PV are more immune to shading effects. There is no magic physics in thin film technologies that make them less tolerant to PV’s number one enemy – partial shading, except that the cells in thin film panels are usually very long and narrow (5 to 10mm wide and the whole length of the panel). In this case, the likelihood of total cell shading is diminished, provided that the installer has correctly oriented the solar modules. Most modern thin film solar modules have further split the narrow cell into multiple sections and incorporated by-pass diodes (4). Nevertheless, if they are not oriented wisely to avoid potential shadows, then it is back to square one (See figure 3).

Figure 3a: Correct orientation to shading           Figure 3b: Incorrect orientation to shading
(Source: Technical Note – Optimising Thin-Film Module PV Systems by SolarEdge)

High Temperature

Finally, how about the claims for superior heat resistance of thin film PV? This is perhaps the only undisputable advantage of thin film technologies – intrinsically, they all have a better temperature coefficient compared to s-Ci (5). In other words, their performance does not degrade as quickly as s-Ci when cell temperatures increase above 25oC.  However, as figure 4 shows, different thin film technologies display a wide variation in temperature response.  Amorphous Silicon (a-Si) is least affected by temperature, whereas CIGS solar panels are very similar in performance to crystalline Silicon.

Fig. 4 Variation of Power Output with Temperature for Different Solar Technologies
 Source: Virtuani. A, Pavanello. D and Friesen. G. Overview of Temperature Coefficient of Different Thin Film Photovoltaic Technologies, 25th European Photovoltaic Solar Energy Conference and Exhibition. 2010, Spain.

A comparative study between amorphous silicon and crystalline silicon suggests the benefit can be up to 20% more output on a hot day with an average ambient temperature of 34oC. See Figure 5. (Note: the tests were published by NexPower, a manufacturer of amorphous Silicon panels).

Figure 4 (Source: NexPower In-house test report)

Although the above result may sound impressive, you may be wondering which parts of the world regularly has an average ambient temperature above 30oC. Unsurprisingly, some research bodies in countries likes, Thailand (6) and India (7), have recommended thin film PV for precisely this reason.

In Summary

Bringing all these factors together, a collaborative research project carried out by Universities of Stuttgart and Cyprus compared thin film PV and c-Si by measuring actual performance over many years in Cyprus (8). The data has obviously taken into account all the differences in spectrum responses and temperature coefficients, the results are summarised in Figure 5.  Data for four years is presented from 2007 (labelled a) to 2010 (labelled d). The clear conclusion from this multi-year side by side test is that thin film modules do not outperform crystalline silicon modules.

Figure 5 Muli-Year Comparison of Solar Energy Yield from Different Technologies
(Source: Reference 8 – page 222)

There appears to be no clear technological advantage for thin-film PV against c-Si at present. In order for thin-film PV to experience a revival, there must be other factors involved which would make thin film PV more attractive than crystalline silicon solar PV. 

For example the homogenous appearance of thin film panels may make them look more appealing.
Thin film solar can be printed on any thickness of substrate and combine with other materials to form see-through graphics, stained glass, company logos, and blinds. With the ability of being semi-transparent, they could even mimic the appearance of natural materials, for example wood or marble.

Needless to say, apart from such niche applications, thin film PV also needs to gain more headroom in cost advantage against c-Si to offset a lower overall efficiency. Until then, it seems like c-Si will stay on top for now.


(1) http://www.marketsandmarkets.com/Market-Reports/thin-film-pv-31.html
Renewable Energy Sources and Climate Change Mitigation: Special Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change
(2) Photovoltaics Report by Fraunhoher Institute for Solar Energy System. 6 June 2016www.ise.fraunhofer.de
(3) FLINS Project (www.flins-projekt.de) hosted by Universitat Oldenburg, Germany (http://www.uni-oldenburg.de/en/physics/research/ehf/energiemeteorology/research/former-projects/flins/).
(4) Correspondence with NexPower (www.nexpw.com )
(5) Overview of Temperature Coefficients of Different Thin Film Photovoltaics Technologies by Alessandro Virtuani, Diego Pavanello, Gabi Friesen at 5th World Conefrence on Photovoltaic Energy Conversion, Spain (https://www.researchgate.net/publication/256080289)
(6) Investigation on Temperature Coefficients of three types Photovoltaic Module Technologies under Thailand Operating Condition by P. Kamkird, N. Ketjoy, W. Rakwichian and S. Sukchai. Published on Procedia Engineering 32 (2012) 376 – 383.
(7) Variation of Temperature Coefficient of different technology Photovoltaic modules with respect to irradiance by P. Dash and N. Gupta. Published on International Journal of Current Engineering and Technology, Vol. 5, No. 1 (Feb 2015).
(8) Performance of Photovoltaics under Actual Operating Conditions by G. Makrides, B. Zinsser, M. Norton and G. Georghiou (pages 201 to 232). Third Generation Photovoltaics ISBN 978-953-51-0304-2. March 2012.


  1. great post. thanks for sharing.

  2. Thanks for the information. Looking forward to longer term studies to see if this is true.

  3. Yeah solar power save our money and energy. Why we don't use this in hot countries like Africa and others.

  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

  5. The links that have been mentioned in your post are very useful. They provide awesome remedy tips of this particular problem.

    Silicon Carbide substrates

  6. I liked the way you wrote the article on thin film solar pv vs silicon wafer. It was very straightforward and your knowledge on the subject is fantastic.

    fused silica wafer

  7. Nice explained about Thin Film Solar PV vs Silicon Wafer - Which is Better? In this article i have collected good information. Keep it up
    fused quartz wafers

  8. After reading the blog writings, a spiritual relation is made between reader and writer.
    holm law group san diego

  9. It is a wonderful reply to the question that has been asked since a longer time. Given answers were so immaculate that will open many eyes. I appreciate your work and want you to write more.

    polished fused silica

  10. I should thank you for writing on this topic, very useful information you have given through this blog regarding education sector. I will visit again to get more information.

    thin ceramic substrates

  11. I was just searching the relevant information on internet to add to my research and I came across to your blog.

    substrate dicing

  12. Thank you so much for your blog. You wrote lot of valuable information in your blog. Now I read your article attentively. I like your post. Thanks for your great post.
    machining alumina ceramic

  13. To begin with, think about your showcasing and circulation design before composing the screenplay. This allows you to consider motion picture item position and other showcasing roads you can compose into the screenplay to support winning potential.putlocker movies

  14. This piece of blog shows dedication of writer.

  15. Thank you so much for sharing. Your content was very helpful. You are a marvelous writer. Good work!
    fused silica substrates

  16. Resolution / Resurrection: Hero is purified by the last sacrifice, by a moment of death and rebirth, but on a higher and more complete level. By the hero's action, the polarities that were in conflict at the beginning are finally resolved.  Hero is transformed and there is a proof that change has occurred and that it’s real. Screenplay resolution

  17. Well I would surmise that for the individuals who have put in the long periods of work to pick up the broad film information and who keep on working hard at refining their aptitudes will feel disappointed by somebody who begins to call themselves a pundit since it sound cool and who imagines that "American Pie 7" is a unique youngster drama, trust me it isn't.Film 2018

  18. select a particular plan, and then create a list of movies they want to watch. According to the details of the chosen plan 123movies

  19. The story is told from the eyes of Picasso mistress Francoise Gilot and features only reproductions of Picasso works. With Anthony Hopkins talent and his physical resemblance to Picasso film genre comedy

  20. So these are the multiple ways for watching movies, videos, music videos and more, although these are only the few websites which are offering streaming, there are thousands of more on which you can stream videos and watch 123movies

  21. Titles were giving, partner and connecting the availability between Baahubali Part 1 and Baahubali-The Conclusion. watch hollywood movies online

  22. Just view a classification that intrigues you, and read the portrayal of any movies that you have not as of now observed.https://movgotv.com/

  23. Silicon wafers are a key segment in incorporated circuits. Coordinated circuits are, basically, a composite of different electronic segments that are organized to play out a particular capacity. Silicon is the standard stage for semiconductor gadgets. Mostly polysilicon wafer supplier also selling silicon wafers for trusted customers.

  24. I must say this is a great comparison between Thin Film Solar PV and Quality Silicon Wafers, Keep up the good work.

  25. Wow, excellent post. I'd like to draft like this too - taking time and real hard work to make a great article. This post has encouraged me to write some posts that I am going to write soon. One Piece tube HDfilme

  26. I will recommend your post to my junior researchers who have the similar doubts. I guess your blog has clear the confusion in very simpler way. Thank you on behalf of them.
    soda lime glass wafers

  27. Incredible Article it its truly instructive and inventive update us as often as possible with new upgrades. its was truly important. much obliged.  watch movies online free full movie no sign up

  28. Anyway you can be extremely shrewd with how you cause your film to occur. I for one have made three films where three months out from the primary day of shooting, we had no cash.best horror movies

  29. So don't quit on the grounds that Netflix does not convey to your home. You out an option online motion picture rental administrations an attempt. solarmovies

  30. Next you should consider the encounters how to watch movies free at 123movies of different clients to check whether the accessible movies to watch offered by the organization are solid or not.

  31. Your article was very impressive; I really appreciate the research you’ve done and that helps make your article rich. Overall you’ve done great work.
    fused silica wafer

  32. The emergence of the various sites that offer online movie rentals has certainly chipped away at the popularity of the traditional brick and mortar DVD rental facility. However,how to stream free movies at 123movieshub you may still prefer to rent from the bricks and mortar type stores.

  33. How would you like to watch your movies? On the off chance that you don't care to trust that movies will be transported out to you, check for different alternatives to suit you for example what number of titles are accessible to download and observe right away on your PC or TV. yes movie

  34. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts. Any way I'll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post again soon. Big thanks for the useful post. 123movies free

  35. very interesting post.this is my first time visit here.i found so mmany interesting stuff in your blog especially its discussion..thanks for the post!
    jadwal film bioskop

  36. They just want to take a break and rest, but you can not, because finishing a movie is only half the battle. It's time to enter the world of film distribution. 123 netflix movies

  37. These participation destinations have a large number of records that you can get to movies, amusements,watch animation movies for free network shows online.